• Home
  • Articles
    • General
    • Mining
    • Change Management
    • Procurement
    • Book Reviews
  • About
  • Newsletter
  • Contact

Digging Deeper – 3rd Party Estimate Reviews II

October 5, 2015

Independent third party estimate reviews are undertaken to give mine owners and their lenders more than just confidence in the quality of the estimate they just paid for.  These cost reviews give the owners insights in to the cost risks involved and a degree of certainty that the project can be completed for this cost (assuming the engineering and design are frozen at that point in time, which is a large assumption).

The reviewer will confirm all supporting documentation, perform ratio analysis, formulae checks, bench marking, labor rate buildup, agree on the indirects, contingency, etc. and work with the estimator to justify reasons for pricing items in a particular way.

While creating a cost estimate may sound simple, cost estimators, engineers, management and executives can make mistakes.

On top of their potential for error, some of the team may have different opinions of a labor rate buildup, productivity factors, contingency, or numbers of hours to install an item. They may also use different reference works when they are available (e.g. piping and electrical reference books are available but usually only cover smaller projects).

In the mining industry, reference works are not publicly available for installation costs of mechanical equipment, major electrical or mine development (e.g. mills, conveyors, mine trucks, flotation cells, large transformers, shaft sinking, etc.).  The cost databases with the greatest accuracy are managed by the large engineering firms or the large project management firms who are able to archive volumes of accurate cost details because of the large number of projects they work on.  It should be noted that these firms often have difficulty capturing owners’ costs for obvious reasons.

Smaller companies and individuals who do not have access to these private cost databases use their own experience or recent and similar estimates (I just said it…. we have seen small companies cut corners by building an estimate from an estimate…. unfortunately this is not uncommon in the mining sector). Most construction contractors don’t retain the actual quantity and cost information due to expense and time constraints.

The difficulty in the mining cycle is that when things are very busy, the estimators are under a lot of pressure to finish the estimates and then go onto the next project estimate.  Now that the estimating teams have been reduced through attrition and redundancy in this down market cycle, cost estimators should be catching up on project costs and updating historical man hours…. assuming their employer cares about the quality of their cost database and is willing to invest during these lean times.

An extra set of eyes is always a good idea, even after the peer reviews, to examine both the process utilized in building an estimate as well as price validity.  Therefore, it is a good idea to understand where the risks are when creating a cost estimate and to manage those risks through a rigorous independent third party review process.

Co-written with Derek Andrew

& Matthew Brook

Share

Mining

John F. Gravel
John is a mining professional with over 22 years of operations and project management experience. He works on the front lines of project delivery as Managing Director of Bedrock-Service, a leading global program management and construction consultancy; supporting organisations that invest in, own and operate assets.

  • Search

  • Sponsors

    Amos & Andes Whistler Sweater Shop

  • Donate

    Donate to Gravel Bedrock.

  • Newsletter

  • Recent Posts

    • Interview with Don Taylor of Arizona Mining
      March 1, 2018
    • Crowdsourcing Your Next Mine
      March 28, 2017
    • Champions' Lessons from Wimbledon
      July 13, 2016


  • Gravel Bedrock - Beneath the surface of Project Management in Mining

    Beneath the surface of Project Management in Mining

  • Newsletter

  • Recent Posts

    • Interview with Don Taylor of Arizona Mining
      March 1, 2018
    • Crowdsourcing Your Next Mine
      March 28, 2017
    • Champions' Lessons from Wimbledon
      July 13, 2016
  • Popular Posts

    • Target Costs Made Easy
      October 25, 2015
    • Digging Deeper - 3rd Party Estimate Reviews II
      October 5, 2015
    • INDEPENDENT THIRD PARTY REVIEWS
      September 27, 2015

© Copyright Gravel Bedrock.